I've been challenged

Joined
May 17, 2015
Messages
38
Reaction score
12
Age
57
Check out the picture I have attached. I have worked in the firehouse to the left for 19 years. The (approx) 350' radio antenna is a couple doors down from work. The guys at the firehouse have challenged me to fly my P3A to within 4' of the top lightbulb and take pics/video.
I am up to date with firmware and app updates and have had no problems at all with the bird. I do need a little more stick time with the bird before the challenge.
My question is... am I going to get any interference from the many antennas on the tower. I know I can take it slow and see how it goes or do a few test runs at different heights to see how it goes but I'm wondering if anybody has undertaken such a flight.
The picture was taken on a foggy/windy day but I'm not going to do the flight unless it's perfect weather.
In case anybody was wondering that is Engine 7/Truck 58/Ambulance 7's house in Chicago and the tower is the old WXRT radio antenna now used for a zillion other antennas.
 

Attachments

Last edited:
Joined
Mar 27, 2014
Messages
515
Reaction score
170
I wouldn't do it in the fog, but otherwise it's a piece of cake. I have flown right up to cell towers with no problem.
 
Joined
Apr 10, 2015
Messages
119
Reaction score
50
Check out the picture I have attached. I have worked in the firehouse to the left for 19 years. The (approx) 350' radio antenna is a couple doors down from work. The guys at the firehouse have challenged me to fly my P3A to within 4' of the top lightbulb and take pics/video.
I am up to date with firmware and app updates and have had no problems at all with the bird. I do need a little more stick time with the bird before the challenge.
My question is... am I going to get any interference from the many antennas on the tower. I know I can take it slow and see how it goes or do a few test runs at different heights to see how it goes but I'm wondering if anybody has undertaken such a flight.
The picture was taken on a foggy/windy day but I'm not going to do the flight unless it's perfect weather.
In case anybody was wondering that is Engine 7's house in Chicago and the tower is the old WXRT radio antenna now used for a zillion other antennas.
Be careful. Some of these transmission towers put out VERY powerful signals. Compare the frequencies in the area with those of your bird. Mine (P2V+V3) uses 2.4 for WiFi and 5.8 for flight control. I live near Mt Wilson in CA. All kinds of antennas there. If you park in the lot there, sometimes the remote car locking won't work for this reason. The power of those antennas could swamp your wifi and flight control signals if they're on the same freq.
 
Joined
May 17, 2015
Messages
38
Reaction score
12
Age
57
Be careful. Some of these transmission towers put out VERY powerful signals. Compare the frequencies in the area with those of your bird. Mine (P2V+V3) uses 2.4 for WiFi and 5.8 for flight control. I live near Mt Wilson in CA. All kinds of antennas there. If you park in the lot there, sometimes the remote car locking won't work for this reason. The power of those antennas could swamp your wifi and flight control signals if they're on the same freq.
That's what I am worried about. I'll have to take it slow and see and pull back if anything starts interfering.
 
Joined
Apr 10, 2015
Messages
119
Reaction score
50
That's what I am worried about. I'll have to take it slow and see and pull back if anything starts interfering.
The problem is that once the signal gets interrupted by a stronger one, especially if it's the flight control or GPS radios, there may be no recovery, as it's path from there is out of your control.
 
Joined
May 17, 2015
Messages
38
Reaction score
12
Age
57
The problem is that once the signal gets interrupted by a stronger one, especially if it's the flight control or GPS radios, there may be no recovery, as it's path from there is out of your control.
Hmmmm...maybe I'll go thru a couple batteries just flying around it before doing a nice slow accent with the 4K on.
 
Joined
Oct 20, 2014
Messages
498
Reaction score
238
Location
Alberta, Canada
I always make my RTH height about 50' higher than the tower. If something does cause signal loss it will hopefully fly above the tower and come home. I did 3 batteries of flying around that tower in the photo while we were working there. At one point I set the P3 in a nice spot and recorded us removing a 6' microwave dish - it just sat there perfectly for the whole battery without issues. I flew over to a cell tower about 1/2km away and had no issues passing near microwave dishes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: skyhighdiver
Joined
Dec 7, 2013
Messages
1,206
Reaction score
136
That's what I am worried about. I'll have to take it slow and see and pull back if anything starts interfering.
Problem is interference could cause your Phantom to do something unexpected without warning and crash before you have the ability to take any corrective measures. My advice is domt do this unless you're okay taking a $1k loss.
 
Joined
Oct 20, 2014
Messages
498
Reaction score
238
Location
Alberta, Canada
The ascents going straight up look awesome in video. If I ever figure out video editing I'll post some clips from that site. I need to do photos and video of all of our sites. The highest tower we own is 400', but there are taller around here. Nothing like the 2000' ones in the east though.
 
Joined
Apr 28, 2014
Messages
24
Reaction score
1
ImageUploadedByPhantomPilots1435418317.391534.jpg
ImageUploadedByPhantomPilots1435418384.671606.jpg



I also work in the cell tower industry and use my drone for pics which often puts the drone in front of the ANT. I've noticed that many of the Antennas are running on 1900Mhz for CDMA, but the latest generations are already running close to 2.5Ghz (Sprint that I know of for sure).

I've noticed on many it doesn't do anything, but on some it does knock the signal strength down significantly. I try to never be closer than 20ft and I haven't lost it or had interference yet.
 
Joined
Apr 28, 2014
Messages
24
Reaction score
1
On the photo on the right I flew all around the platform, so I was at times at the same level as the ANTs
 

TAZ

Joined
Jun 11, 2015
Messages
186
Reaction score
121
I think you could do it quite safely and have a greater chance of technically meeting the challenge...if you do it wisely. Radio transmitters are designed to broadcast radially, not vertically (same reason why you orient your own RC antennas with the flat edge to face your bird rather than point the tip straight at it, for best signal). With this in mind, set your Failsafe altitude to 400'. Then when you fly your bird, do so as far away from the tower as you can, climb to altitude, until you reach 400'. Then orient yourself at altitude directly over the tip of the tower and descend straight down slowly until you are 4' away. Doing it this way you'll be avoid passing through the strongest RF interference as you ascend/descend.

After you've met the challenge, ascend back to 400', fly well clear of the tower and descend to home.

I wouldn't recommend you ascend/descend anywhere near the tower, as any loss of control could cause you to crash into it. Descending onto the tip of the tower will help you to avoid intersecting a fair amount of the emanating interference. Worse case, you'll loose contact, and the bird will climb to 400' and return home...or drift horizontally...but being above the obstruction, you won't it hit.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Synnic and DrChris
Joined
Oct 20, 2014
Messages
498
Reaction score
238
Location
Alberta, Canada
Flight path and safety is going to depend on what is actually on the tower for transmitters. Do you know what's there?

From the photo is doesn't look like cell at all. Likely just UHF of VHF for your firehall and emerg services. Probably nothing high power. I'm sure you will be fine. I would do it, but that's me.
 
Joined
Jan 4, 2015
Messages
429
Reaction score
135
Location
Bakersfield, Ca.
I work on comm towers. It's easy to film them. Self support is the best as there are no guy wires. HahaView attachment 23125
Don't they turn those off before you go up? In the navy it was do not rotate or radiate men working aloft. and I think that's how the microwave oven was invented, a candy bar melted in a guys pocket.
 

New Threads

Forum statistics

Threads
135,453
Messages
1,401,443
Members
98,660
Latest member
Brooklyn's Daddy