Drone suicided into wall, ignoring my commands, goes to right instead of straight and left

Joined
Mar 3, 2021
Messages
3
Reaction score
1
Age
28
Hi,
My DJI died whilst flying under a bridge. it moved itself to the right instead of to the front, ignoring my commands, also ignoring my correction (Full throttle) to the left. whilst being very close to the drone. In all other cases it did not pose a problem to fly under a bridge in an urban environment nor a narrow tunnel without gps with strong wind effects, as can be seen here.
This is inconsistent behavior at best and crappy programming at worst. Pilot control should be leading at all times, and if GPS loss was such a problem, it could have defered my vector (direction+speed) from just before losing gps. This is my 4th mavic lost to their programming. The 3rd randomly took a plunge whilst stationary (reimbursed), the 2nd was losing connection within 400m range and not returning, the first suicided into a tree without my command right after takeoff.

Are there any alternatives out there with similar camera quality and portability as the m2p which is not DJI?

I have a video. showing my controls at the accident, an earlier, similar accident, and cases where the mavic was functioning normally.

Attached are the flight logs of my last flight + the flight before where it did not return to home when it was supposed to but went moving further from home.

 

ianzone

**P4**
Joined
May 22, 2016
Messages
6,901
Reaction score
4,657
Age
51
Location
NZ
4th mavic,, should look at a phantom,might last longer,,unsure with reading flight log but before sideways impact you can see it got no GPS so it's going to drift,,as for the tree impact it didn't look like it respond to you stick inputs so mayby a stick calibration was needed before,,,,this just speculation until someone can read you flight ,,not a fan of these newer mavics but still major bummer to have this happen
 

dirkclod

Moderator
Staff Member
Premium Pilot
Joined
May 9, 2014
Messages
15,413
Reaction score
9,297
Age
66
Location
Amory Mississippi
Hi,
My DJI died whilst flying under a bridge. it moved itself to the right instead of to the front, ignoring my commands, also ignoring my correction (Full throttle) to the left. whilst being very close to the drone. In all other cases it did not pose a problem to fly under a bridge in an urban environment nor a narrow tunnel without gps with strong wind effects, as can be seen here.
This is inconsistent behavior at best and crappy programming at worst. Pilot control should be leading at all times, and if GPS loss was such a problem, it could have defered my vector (direction+speed) from just before losing gps. This is my 4th mavic lost to their programming. The 3rd randomly took a plunge whilst stationary (reimbursed), the 2nd was losing connection within 400m range and not returning, the first suicided into a tree without my command right after takeoff.

Are there any alternatives out there with similar camera quality and portability as the m2p which is not DJI?

I have a video. showing my controls at the accident, an earlier, similar accident, and cases where the mavic was functioning normally.

Attached are the flight logs of my last flight + the flight before where it did not return to home when it was supposed to but went moving further from home.

I don’t read files but @Meta4 does and if your going to stay with Mavics I would join our sister forum. DJI Mavic Drone Forum.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Order66
Joined
Mar 3, 2021
Messages
3
Reaction score
1
Age
28
I am one clue closer, false obstacle detection probably blocked my controls at the crucial moments, as it sometimes also did in mid air. when there were no birds around.
Proper input, risky location, bad and improper handling by drone.
 

Meta4

Moderator
Staff Member
Premium Pilot
Joined
Jan 8, 2014
Messages
14,745
Reaction score
8,741
I don’t read files but @Meta4 does and if your going to stay with Mavics I would join our sister forum. DJI Mavic Drone Forum.
The data from this incident has already been looked into over there:
 
  • Like
Reactions: dirkclod
Joined
Jun 17, 2019
Messages
146
Reaction score
45
Location
Wisconsin
Hi,
My DJI died whilst flying under a bridge. it moved itself to the right instead of to the front, ignoring my commands, also ignoring my correction (Full throttle) to the left. whilst being very close to the drone. In all other cases it did not pose a problem to fly under a bridge in an urban environment nor a narrow tunnel without gps with strong wind effects, as can be seen here.
This is inconsistent behavior at best and crappy programming at worst. Pilot control should be leading at all times, and if GPS loss was such a problem, it could have defered my vector (direction+speed) from just before losing gps. This is my 4th mavic lost to their programming. The 3rd randomly took a plunge whilst stationary (reimbursed), the 2nd was losing connection within 400m range and not returning, the first suicided into a tree without my command right after takeoff.

Are there any alternatives out there with similar camera quality and portability as the m2p which is not DJI?

I have a video. showing my controls at the accident, an earlier, similar accident, and cases where the mavic was functioning normally.

Attached are the flight logs of my last flight + the flight before where it did not return to home when it was supposed to but went moving further from home.

There's the Autel Evo 2, it's similar to the mavic.
 
Joined
Mar 5, 2021
Messages
8
Reaction score
6
Age
52
English please per posting guidelines
Estoy una pista más cerca, la detección de obstáculos falsos probablemente bloqueó mis controles en los momentos cruciales, como a veces también lo hacía en el aire. cuando no había pájaros alrededor.
Entrada adecuada, ubicación de riesgo, manejo inadecuado o inadecuado por parte del dron.
Me imagino que los sensores ópticos los tenías bien calibrados, el que en vuelo te arroje “falsas alarmas de obstáculos” muchas veces se debe a los rayos del Sol que le dan a los sensores y estos lo interpretan con un obstáculo, en espacios abiertos en vuelo es mejor desconectarlos, pero en el caso como el del video que nos muestras, puede ser uno de los factores que se sumó al accidente que tuviste...
 
Joined
Dec 6, 2019
Messages
205
Reaction score
187
Age
104
Hi,
My DJI died whilst flying under a bridge. it moved itself to the right instead of to the front, ignoring my commands, also ignoring my correction (Full throttle) to the left. whilst being very close to the drone. In all other cases it did not pose a problem to fly under a bridge in an urban environment nor a narrow tunnel without gps with strong wind effects, as can be seen here.
This is inconsistent behavior at best and crappy programming at worst. Pilot control should be leading at all times, and if GPS loss was such a problem, it could have defered my vector (direction+speed) from just before losing gps. This is my 4th mavic lost to their programming. The 3rd randomly took a plunge whilst stationary (reimbursed), the 2nd was losing connection within 400m range and not returning, the first suicided into a tree without my command right after takeoff.

Are there any alternatives out there with similar camera quality and portability as the m2p which is not DJI?

I have a video. showing my controls at the accident, an earlier, similar accident, and cases where the mavic was functioning normally.

Attached are the flight logs of my last flight + the flight before where it did not return to home when it was supposed to but went moving further from home.

I can sure relate to that. My first couple of flights with my P4P were a bear. Knees knocked so loud it sounded like I had a woodpecker in my pants. When I moved the stick to go left, it went right, forward, it went backwards and throttle up made it land hard. Was on my 4th P4P when I discovered I was holding the controller backwards! Silly me....
 
  • Like
Reactions: MTO
Joined
Sep 19, 2019
Messages
29
Reaction score
6
Age
57
Obstacle detection, false or otherwise, would typically stop my drone - not cause it to move.
Side, obstacle detection on Mavic 2 Pro and Phantom 4 Pro, only work in Tripod mode. I don't know if that was what you were relying on for detection. I never realized that and lost the Mavic Pro into trees and a hill side...ouch!
 
  • Like
Reactions: MTO

New Threads

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
140,509
Messages
1,448,379
Members
102,302
Latest member
Empyreus