[CLOSED] Is this real?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Apr 28, 2015
Messages
248
Reaction score
89
<iframe width="560" height="315" src="
" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

Two things make me suspect that this is faked.

1. it looks like the guy flying it was driving a vehicle with emergency lights on it, making me think he was one of the firefighters.

2. The video goes to static when the water hits the drone, as far as I know that is not what happens when you lose signal, i think it was added in post production.
 
Joined
Jun 27, 2015
Messages
88
Reaction score
21
Age
101
The original video didn't have the static at all, I saw him landing it at the end of the video.
 

msinger

Approved Vendor
Joined
Oct 30, 2014
Messages
31,266
Reaction score
10,433
Location
Harrisburg, PA (US)
Yes, it's real. That's not the original video. Someone cut off the end where the Phantom flies away without any problems.
 
Joined
Dec 21, 2014
Messages
468
Reaction score
94
Location
Northern NJ
I saw that video when it was first posted by some guy. I couldn't see any anomalies. I was surprised the poster was bragging about it and blaming the firefighters on an easily accessible forum.
 
Joined
Jun 22, 2015
Messages
33
Reaction score
8
Age
50
That video made the news few weeks ago, like msinger said- cut at end
 
D

DrewFlies

Guest
I saw that video when it was first posted by some guy. I couldn't see any anomalies. I was surprised the poster was bragging about it and blaming the firefighters on an easily accessible forum.
He didn't do anything wrong. Why wouldn't he be able to brag. This is a very informing video. Other firefighters can actually see aerial view of burning houses and experience what its like in real situations. The firefighters are just asses. The only reason I can see them wanting to shoot down the phantom is because they don't want any proof of the lazy sobs sitting in front of the house doing nothing pointing fingers at the one guy who is actually trying to put the fire out.
 
Joined
Dec 21, 2014
Messages
468
Reaction score
94
Location
Northern NJ
As a volunteer EMS I can state that more robust platforms have proven to be very helpful in aerial views of search and rescue and finding people stuck in houses after a natural disaster. That being said, there have been several issues lately with drones getting in the way of missions which is more than a nuisance and can put lives in danger. It reminds me of the movie Nightcrawler where Jake G's character was getting in the face of victims for the news closeup while paramedics are fighting to save the person's life. You can judge the firefighters' response all you want but unless you know their protocols then you probably should stay silent. As for the guy who posted it, I would be cautious right now on these types of issues. The authorities confiscated an owner's drone just for flying next to a Veteran's Admin location. I'd rather be safe than sorry.
 
D

DrewFlies

Guest
As a volunteer EMS I can state that more robust platforms have proven to be very helpful in aerial views of search and rescue and finding people stuck in houses after a natural disaster. That being said, there have been several issues lately with drones getting in the way of missions which is more than a nuisance and can put lives in danger. It reminds me of the movie Nightcrawler where Jake G's character was getting in the face of victims for the news closeup while paramedics are fighting to save the person's life. You can judge the firefighters' response all you want but unless you know their protocols then you probably should stay silent. As for the guy who posted it, I would be cautious right now on these types of issues. The authorities confiscated an owner's drone just for flying next to a Veteran's Admin location. I'd rather be safe than sorry.

Oh can it. I couldn't even finish half of your paragraph. A nuisance really? This guy wasn't doing anything wrong. Tell those fat lazy sobs sitting around doing nothing to actually do something. If this were my video I would be sure to send it to their chief for informing rookie fighters and to see what he has to say about our people paying for these guys to sit in a driveway and stare at a house burning.
 
D

DrewFlies

Guest
Sounds like your anti quad copter buddy and you shouldn't be in this fourm. This forum is not to point out all the wrongs of quad copters and how there potentially dangerous. Its to point out how beneficial they can be. Go find another forum to rant in like your retired ems fourm.
 
Joined
Dec 16, 2014
Messages
534
Reaction score
214
Location
North Carolina US
where is Mal, the troll cop when ya need him......
 
Joined
Apr 28, 2015
Messages
248
Reaction score
89
As a volunteer EMS I can state that more robust platforms have proven to be very helpful in aerial views of search and rescue and finding people stuck in houses after a natural disaster. That being said, there have been several issues lately with drones getting in the way of missions which is more than a nuisance and can put lives in danger. It reminds me of the movie Nightcrawler where Jake G's character was getting in the face of victims for the news closeup while paramedics are fighting to save the person's life. You can judge the firefighters' response all you want but unless you know their protocols then you probably should stay silent. As for the guy who posted it, I would be cautious right now on these types of issues. The authorities confiscated an owner's drone just for flying next to a Veteran's Admin location. I'd rather be safe than sorry.

In what way was the drone being a nuisance?
 
Joined
Dec 21, 2014
Messages
468
Reaction score
94
Location
Northern NJ
In what way was the drone being a nuisance?
If you look at the end of the video, you can see how close the drone actually was to the fire. I'm sorry but the P2 (maybe not the P3 as much) makes a lot of noise within a few hundred feet. It is really not for the firefighters to have to deal with someone inhibiting an effort in such a manner. The fact that I'm called a troll and that I am somehow anti "quadcopter" (What does that even mean?) shows me perhaps this forum is taking a turn for the worse and perhaps I should spend my time on another forum. Between all the name calling and Abspapa crapping all over every thread I'm kind of getting tired of this infighting. You can disagree with me but you don't need to call people names as ad hominem attacks do nothing to raise the level of discourse here.
 
Joined
Jul 1, 2015
Messages
10
Reaction score
4
Age
57
As a volunteer EMS I can state that more robust platforms have proven to be very helpful in aerial views of search and rescue and finding people stuck in houses after a natural disaster. That being said, there have been several issues lately with drones getting in the way of missions which is more than a nuisance and can put lives in danger. It reminds me of the movie Nightcrawler where Jake G's character was getting in the face of victims for the news closeup while paramedics are fighting to save the person's life. You can judge the firefighters' response all you want but unless you know their protocols then you probably should stay silent. As for the guy who posted it, I would be cautious right now on these types of issues. The authorities confiscated an owner's drone just for flying next to a Veteran's Admin location. I'd rather be safe than sorry.
Usual response from a firefighter when they get called out they know it all and you can't talk or use simple logic with them. What they say is how it is and there is no exceptions. I was in law enforcement and they would come in and act if they where in charge and that we needed to leave the area. Lots of arrogance!
 

TLM

Joined
Jun 23, 2015
Messages
23
Reaction score
5
Age
49
Usual response from a firefighter when they get called out they know it all and you can't talk or use simple logic with them. What they say is how it is and there is no exceptions. I was in law enforcement and they would come in and act if they where in charge and that we needed to leave the area. Lots of arrogance!
Throw a few in a car and they stop that.
 

ianwood

Taco Wrangler
Joined
Jan 7, 2014
Messages
5,109
Reaction score
2,042
Location
Lost Angeles
Status
Not open for further replies.

New Threads

Forum statistics

Threads
139,307
Messages
1,437,357
Members
101,179
Latest member
UAmetry