Does this seem like satisfactory level of wobble/drift?

Joined
Jun 28, 2015
Messages
175
Reaction score
38
Age
42
Location
Illinois
Hello everyone!

Just repaired my P2V+ v3.0 and would like to see what the experts think about the level of wobble/drift I'm observing. Haven't had it long enough to rely on my own feelings about it.

Summary/recap: Busted an arm in a crash, LEDs were blown out and motor scuffed (although it runs). I replaced the shell and the ESC. Still has old motor just because it hasn't arrived yet and I figured I'd test things so far.

Then I did advanced IMU recalibration with the drone perfectly balanced. All settings look good.

I observe a little wobble/drift although ten times better than before replacing ESC and doing a carefully balanced IMU calibration. Here's the video:


I never touch the controls during the video. What do you think? Is it ok? Still unacceptable? Could replacing the motor fix it? Thanks for your thoughts!

Josh
 
Joined
May 13, 2015
Messages
305
Reaction score
27
Age
70
I just replaced motors and ESC's on mine, and that amount of drift is comparable to what I have. With no wind at all, the drift is 1/2 to 1/3 of what your video shows.

Interesting that your motors have a very high pitch noise. At least one of mine does, too, and I figured it was bad bearings.
 
Joined
Jun 28, 2015
Messages
175
Reaction score
38
Age
42
Location
Illinois
Just took it on an untethered flight and it was even less stable. When actually trying to fly a direction, it will have a real rough time maintaining altitude, will either tend up or down. Definitely hoping the new motor helps. :)
 
Joined
May 13, 2015
Messages
305
Reaction score
27
Age
70
When you have it out again, try flipping the left switch top to bottom rapidly 5 times, when you have it over a spot you want to be your home point. That resets the home point. You should see the green lights flash rapidly if it worked. When I do that, I find that my Phantom hovers in a much more stable fashion than it does with just acquiring the satellites. I don't know why yet.
 
Joined
Dec 31, 2014
Messages
1,089
Reaction score
511
Location
West Coast of Florida
What props are you using? Hard to tell for sure from the video but I don't see the black hub on any of them. Are they balanced?
 
Joined
Jun 28, 2015
Messages
175
Reaction score
38
Age
42
Location
Illinois
What props are you using? Hard to tell for sure from the video but I don't see the black hub on any of them. Are they balanced?

Marlin, you may win the prize! I'm not sure, but I did three things and now it flies rock solid, like new, what I'm used to! Here's what I changed:
  • I had two cheap knock-off props from China, and two DJI props. In hindsight, this was completely stupid. They were supposed to be self-tightening thrust boosted props similar to the ones that come standard with P2V+ v3.0, but I'm wondering if they really are. I put 3 original props and one replacement (but genuine DJI) prop on. I haven't balanced them yet (balancer is in the mail).
  • Before I was flying without the camera/gimbal. I reattached them, wondering if the lost weight meant the gains were a bit high, which would contribute to oscillating.
  • I did yet another carefully-balanced advanced IMU calibration.
So I don't know if the props fixed it, or the camera/gimbal weight, or both compounding each other, but it flies SOLID now!!! Rejoice with me, friends!! I repaired my drone and it flies like a champ!!! I am mega excited!!!!!!

Josh :cool::D
 
Joined
May 13, 2015
Messages
305
Reaction score
27
Age
70
Congratulations!

I think the Phantom would be a bit top-heavy without the gimbal, so if I'm not going to be doing a video, I mount a broken gimbal on mine just for weight and balance.

As for the cheap props, there's enough Youtube videos comparing them to DJI to convince me that the extra $$ is worth it.

Now don't crash it. ;)
 
Joined
Jun 28, 2015
Messages
175
Reaction score
38
Age
42
Location
Illinois
Amen!
 
Joined
Dec 31, 2014
Messages
1,089
Reaction score
511
Location
West Coast of Florida
Marlin, you may win the prize! I'm not sure, but I did three things and now it flies rock solid, like new, what I'm used to! Here's what I changed:
  • I had two cheap knock-off props from China, and two DJI props. In hindsight, this was completely stupid. They were supposed to be self-tightening thrust boosted props similar to the ones that come standard with P2V+ v3.0, but I'm wondering if they really are. I put 3 original props and one replacement (but genuine DJI) prop on. I haven't balanced them yet (balancer is in the mail).
  • Before I was flying without the camera/gimbal. I reattached them, wondering if the lost weight meant the gains were a bit high, which would contribute to oscillating.
  • I did yet another carefully-balanced advanced IMU calibration.
So I don't know if the props fixed it, or the camera/gimbal weight, or both compounding each other, but it flies SOLID now!!! Rejoice with me, friends!! I repaired my drone and it flies like a champ!!! I am mega excited!!!!!!

Josh :cool::D

Glad to hear you figured it out. It does sound like it may have been a combination. Mismatched props is definitely a nono.
 

New Threads

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
140,635
Messages
1,449,471
Members
102,438
Latest member
safeharbour